Why Dog and Cat Are Enemies

A Chinese animal tale about cooperation, ingratitude and how one unfair decision turned two companions against each other.
Dog and cat beside a fireplace after the cat receives praise for recovering a golden ring.

Long ago, a dog and a cat lived together in the home of a man and his wife. The couple had once enjoyed a comfortable life, but their fortune changed after they unknowingly sold a valuable golden ring. Neither they nor the animals understood that the ring was responsible for the household’s good fortune.

As the family’s circumstances worsened, even the dog and cat began to suffer from hunger. Determined to help their owners recover their former prosperity, the two animals came together to find a solution.

The Lost Golden Ring

The dog eventually suggested that they must recover the golden ring. The cat explained that it had been carefully locked inside a chest and would be difficult to retrieve.

The dog, however, had already thought of a plan. He advised the cat to catch a mouse and persuade it to gnaw through the chest. The mouse would then be able to remove the ring. If it refused to cooperate, the cat could threaten to bite it.

The cat agreed that the plan might work. She went out, caught a mouse and prepared to take it to the house where the chest was kept.

The dog accompanied her on the journey. Before long, they reached a broad river that stood between them and their destination. The cat could not swim, so the dog offered to carry her across.

Explore more stories from our The Chinese Fairy Book collection.

With the cat on his back, the dog swam through the river and safely reached the opposite bank. The cat then continued towards the house, taking the mouse with her.

The Mouse Retrieves the Ring

When they arrived, the cat brought the mouse to the chest. Following the arrangement, the mouse gnawed a hole through it until it could reach the golden ring.

The mouse successfully retrieved the valuable object and brought it out. The cat immediately took the ring into her mouth, ready to return it to the owners.

She went back to the river, where the dog was waiting. Once again, the dog carried her safely across the water. Having completed this difficult part of their journey together, the two animals set off towards home.

They were both eager to return the ring because they knew how much their owners needed it. They hoped its recovery would restore the family’s lost good fortune and put an end to their hunger.

The Cat Arrives Home First

Although the dog and cat travelled together, they did not move in the same way. The dog could only run along the ground. Whenever a house or another building stood in his path, he had to go around it.

The cat had a different advantage. She could climb over rooftops and cross from one building to another. This allowed her to take a shorter route and move much faster.

Before the dog could reach home, the cat had already arrived. She presented the golden ring to her master and mistress, who were delighted to see the valuable object returned.

The master praised the cat for what he believed was a wonderful act of service. He declared that she was a good creature and promised that she would always have enough food. He also said that they would care for her as though she were their own child.

The cat sat comfortably beside the fireplace, pleased with the welcome she had received.

An Unfair Reward

When the dog eventually arrived, he expected his owners to be equally pleased. After all, he had helped plan the recovery of the ring and had carried the cat across the river twice.

Instead of receiving praise, he was beaten and scolded. His owners believed that he had failed to help bring back the ring and did not recognise the important part he had played.

The cat remained beside the fireplace, purring quietly. She said nothing about the dog’s assistance and allowed the couple to believe that she alone had recovered the valuable object.

The dog was deeply hurt and angry. He had worked alongside the cat, helped her overcome the river and contributed to the success of their mission. Yet she had received all the praise while he suffered punishment.

He came to regard the cat as someone who had stolen his reward and betrayed their partnership.

From that day onwards, whenever the dog saw the cat, he chased her and tried to catch her. The friendship they had once shared was replaced by hostility.

And that, according to the tale, was how dogs and cats became enemies.

Explore our complete Historic Folklore & Fairy-Tale Collections archive.

Moral Lessons

Cooperation is important when people or companions work towards a common goal. The dog and cat succeeded because they combined their different abilities. The dog devised the plan and helped with the difficult river crossing, while the cat handled the mouse and retrieved the ring.

Fairness matters when recognising the efforts of others. The dog contributed significantly to the recovery of the ring but received neither appreciation nor a reward. His owners judged him without understanding what he had done.

The story also warns against taking credit for another person’s work. The cat benefited from the dog’s assistance but remained silent when he was unfairly blamed. Her silence destroyed the trust between them.

Finally, the tale shows how resentment can grow when people feel betrayed. Instead of remaining companions, the dog and cat became enemies because one was praised while the other’s contribution was ignored.

Knowledge Check

1. What valuable object did the couple sell?
They sold a golden ring that brought good fortune to whoever owned it.

2. Why did the dog and cat decide to recover the ring?
They wanted to restore their owners’ good fortune because the household had become poor and everyone, including the animals, was going hungry.

3. How did the dog help the cat cross the river?
He carried her on his back and swam across the river with her.

4. How did the mouse help recover the ring?
The mouse gnawed a hole through the chest and retrieved the ring.

5. Why did the cat reach home before the dog?
She could climb over rooftops, while the dog had to travel along the ground and go around buildings.

6. Why did the dog begin chasing the cat?
He became angry because the cat received all the praise while he was beaten and scolded, despite helping her recover the ring.

Source

This retelling is based on “Why Dog and Cat Are Enemies”, Chapter XIV, page 30, in The Chinese Fairy Book (1921), edited by Richard Wilhelm and translated from original sources by Frederick H. Martens.

Explore More On The Chinese Fairy Book

author avatar
Elizabeth Fabowale
Go toTop

Don't Miss

Young Japanese woman holding the mirror of Matsuyama inside a traditional home.

The Mirror of Matsuyama

Long ago, in the Province of Echigo in Japan, there
A wolf confronts a lamb drinking from a stream in The Wolf and the Lamb.

The Wolf and the Lamb

The Wolf and the Lamb is a well-known fable