Mr. Rabbit Nibbles Up the Butter is a traditional animal tale recorded by Joel Chandler Harris in his collection of Uncle Remus stories. It follows Brer Rabbit, Brer Fox and Brer Possum as they work together to repair a leaking roof. When Rabbit discovers some butter stored for their meal, his appetite leads him into a dishonest scheme. Rather than accept responsibility, he shifts the blame onto an innocent companion. The consequences reveal how deception can destroy trust and cause suffering to those who have done nothing wrong.
The Three Companions and the Stored Butter
Brer Rabbit, Brer Fox and Brer Possum had become accustomed to sharing their provisions. They lived together in a small dwelling, and when the roof began to leak, the three companions decided to repair it.
They prepared for a long day’s work by bringing food for their meal. The provisions were gathered in one place, but Brer Fox had brought some butter that needed to remain cool. He therefore placed it inside a nearby spring-house before they began working.
The three animals set about repairing the roof. At first, Brer Rabbit worked alongside his companions, but his thoughts soon turned towards the butter. He imagined its rich taste and found it increasingly difficult to concentrate on the work.
Eventually, he decided to take some without telling the others.
While they were busy, Rabbit suddenly raised his head and called out as though someone had summoned him. He hurried away, making his companions believe that he had an urgent matter to attend to.
Once he was certain that nobody was following him, he entered the spring-house and ate a little of the butter. Satisfied, he returned to the others and continued working.
Brer Fox noticed his absence and asked where he had gone. Rabbit explained that he had heard his children calling and needed to check on his wife, who was supposedly very ill.
His excuse was accepted.
Rabbit Returns for More Butter
The taste of the butter remained in Rabbit’s mind. After some time, his appetite overcame him again. He repeated his earlier trick, calling out as though he had been summoned before hurrying away.
This time, he remained away for longer. When he returned, Brer Fox again wanted to know where he had been.
Rabbit claimed that he had visited his wife and that her condition was becoming worse. His companions believed him and allowed him to continue with the work.
Explore more stories from our Uncle Remus & Br’er Rabbit Tales collection
Before long, Rabbit made another journey to the spring-house. He ate so much butter that he left the container completely empty. He then returned to the others, pretending to be troubled by the illness of his wife.
When Brer Fox asked about her condition, Rabbit suggested that she might already have died. His companions felt sympathy for him, believing that he was dealing with a family tragedy.
The three animals eventually stopped working for their meal. Brer Fox and Brer Possum began arranging the food, but Rabbit remained unusually quiet and appeared sorrowful.
The Missing Butter
When it was time to eat, Brer Fox asked Brer Possum to fetch the butter from the spring-house. Possum hurried off to collect it, expecting to find it where Fox had left it.
However, he soon returned in alarm. The butter had disappeared.
Brer Fox could hardly believe the news. He wanted to know what had happened to it, but Possum could only explain that the container was empty.
Rabbit pretended to examine the situation carefully. He suggested that someone must have eaten the butter, making a remark that hinted at the thief without identifying anyone.
The three companions went to inspect the spring-house. They found that the butter was indeed gone. While they discussed the disappearance, Rabbit claimed to have noticed tracks around the place.
He then proposed a plan to discover the culprit. If the three of them went to sleep, he said, he could remain awake and catch whoever had stolen the butter.
Brer Fox and Brer Possum agreed.
Rabbit Frames Brer Possum
The three animals settled down to rest. Fox and Possum soon fell asleep, but Rabbit remained awake.
When he was certain that his companions were sleeping soundly, he quietly approached Possum. Using the butter on his own paws, he smeared some around Possum’s mouth. He then helped himself to the best part of the remaining meal before returning to his place.
Afterwards, Rabbit woke Brer Fox and showed him the butter around Possum’s mouth.
When Possum was awakened and confronted, he denied stealing anything. He knew he had not eaten the butter, but the evidence appeared to be against him.
Brer Fox reasoned that Possum had been the first to visit the spring-house and the first to discover that the butter was missing. Now there was butter around his mouth. To Fox, these details seemed to prove that Possum was responsible.
Possum realised that his companions were unlikely to believe his denial. He therefore suggested another way to identify the thief.
The Test by Fire
Possum proposed that they build a large heap of dry brush and set it alight. Once the flames were burning strongly, each animal would take a turn jumping over the fire. According to his suggestion, whoever fell into the flames would be the one who had stolen the butter.
Brer Rabbit and Brer Fox accepted the proposal.
Together, they gathered the brush and built a large heap. When it was ready, they set it on fire and waited until the flames rose high.
Rabbit volunteered to jump first. He stepped back, gathered himself and crossed the burning heap safely. He appeared pleased with his success.
Brer Fox took the next turn. He moved farther back before making his attempt. He managed to cross, although the end of his tail caught fire as he passed over the flames.
Uncle Remus explains that the white tip found on a fox’s tail is a lasting mark of that encounter.
Possum prepared for his turn. Unlike the other two, he did not manage to cross safely. He took a running start and leapt towards the burning heap, but landed directly in the middle of the flames.
He died there, and his companions could no longer help him.
The Innocent Victim
The little boy listening to Uncle Remus was troubled by the ending. He pointed out that Brer Possum had not stolen the butter and had therefore suffered for something he had not done.
Uncle Remus acknowledged the injustice. He explained that innocent people sometimes suffer because of the wrong actions of others. The punishment may fall on someone who did not commit the offence, while the guilty person escapes responsibility.
The story ends with this reflection, leaving the listener to consider the unfairness of Possum’s fate.
Explore our complete Historic Folklore & Fairy-Tale Collections archive.
Moral Lessons
Dishonesty can cause serious harm, especially when someone tries to escape responsibility by blaming another person. Brer Rabbit’s greed leads him to steal from his companions, but his decision to frame Possum makes the situation far worse.
The tale also warns against accepting appearances as proof. Brer Fox judges Possum by the butter around his mouth without considering that someone could have placed it there. His failure to investigate the evidence properly contributes to an innocent animal’s death.
Another lesson concerns the danger of unfair judgement. Possum suffers because his companions trust misleading evidence instead of listening carefully to his denial. The story reminds readers that accusations should be examined before anyone is condemned.
Knowledge Check
1. Why did Brer Rabbit, Brer Fox and Brer Possum decide to work together?
They wanted to repair the leaking roof of their dwelling.
2. Where did Brer Fox keep the butter?
He placed it in a spring-house to keep it cool.
3. What excuse did Brer Rabbit give for repeatedly leaving the work?
He claimed that his children had called him and that his wife was seriously ill.
4. How did Brer Rabbit make Possum appear guilty?
He smeared butter around Possum’s mouth while he was asleep.
5. What test did Possum suggest to identify the thief?
He proposed that they jump over a large burning heap of brush.
6. What happened to Brer Possum at the end of the tale?
He fell into the fire and died, although he had not stolen the butter.
Source
This tale comes from Joel Chandler Harris’s Uncle Remus: His Songs and His Sayings, first published in 1881. It appears as Chapter XVII, “Mr. Rabbit nibbles up the Butter,” in the section titled “Legends of the Old Plantation.”
Explore More Uncle Remus & Br’er Rabbit Tales